Family of Three
Posted by Elizabeth
The goal seemed simple enough: to watch A Christmas Story before the day was out. The week leading up to December 25 had been a flurry of activity, filled with last-minute shopping excursions, a dinner party with new friends, a trip to the Mexican grocer for special cuts of meat to make my mother-in-law’s posole. But now the whole day stretched before us, long and languorous. There would be plenty of time for relaxation and leisure, for watching movies and opening gifts, for basking in the warmth of our first Christmas as a family of three. Even the ham, ordered from a small smokehouse in Kentucky, came fully cooked.
I awoke at 1:45 am, three and a half hours earlier than normal, upon hearing Abra’s cries through the baby monitor. Usually an efficient eater, she nursed for nearly an hour, and then I was up at six, this time for good. Bleary-eyed, I put on the coffee and started the balloon buns, a sugary breakfast bread that my mother made every Christmas morning growing up. Before I knew it it was 10 am, and we hadn’t touched any of the small mountain of gifts that had multiplied under the tree – many for a baby that was unaware of what day it was. Fussy and malcontented, Maikael and I took turns dandling Abra on our knee while we peeked into stockings and tore through wrapping paper. Normally a process that we give time and attention to, our focus was fractured and diffuse. “Why don’t we take a break?” Maikael offered, but time felt as if it was weighing heavily upon me. Abra’s mood steadily declined, and soon a “let’s just get through this” attitude took hold. Already feeling harassed, I dashed into the kitchen to take the balloon buns from the oven, only to find the $16 marshmallows from Williams-Sonoma I had tucked into the dough now lacquered to my muffin tin, creating an oozing mess.
Determined to create the special memories I had planned, I decided it would be an ideal time to take Christmas photos. My Aunt Nancy created a beautiful needlepoint stocking for Abra, and I was eager to capture a few shots of her in her sweet plaid Christmas dress holding the stocking that contained the one gift I had purchased for her: a grossly overpriced wooden rattle that, I was sure, would be passed down through the generations. Abra showed zero interest in the toy, quickly dropping it in favor of a cheap, plastic ring, and tugged at the faux fur collar on her dress until she dissolved into tears. Still in our pajamas, we propped Abra on our laps to make video calls to our parents: she slept through the call to my dad, her head lolling in the crook of Maikael’s arm, and cried through the call to my mother-in-law.
Night had fallen, and with a crying baby strapped to me I scurried around the kitchen whipping up side dishes to accompany our ham, leaving a wake of dirty pots and pans. I congratulated myself on having made the decision earlier in the week to buy store-bought rolls. By the time we sat down to dinner at the dining room table the china had been pushed aside in favor of our everyday dishes, paper napkins were slung across our laps, the candles sat unlit, Abra’s tights sagged around her ankles, and I popped two aspirin along with my glass of wine.
Later that evening, as I sat in the soft glow of the Christmas tree and quietly nursed Abra, I flipped through my friend’s photos of their Christmases on Facebook. Here I saw a twirling carousel of happy memories, smiling children, clinking glasses, annual traditions, plenty of good cheery. Reflected back at me was the Christmas I had hoped for myself, and I couldn’t help but feel overcome by sadness as I wondered where I had gone wrong. In the weeks leading up to Christmas I had been the envy of the new mothers I know. “How lucky you are,” they said, “to get to set your own traditions as a family of three.” But the day had passed in an inky blur, a parade of unmet, unrealistic expectations, filled with more tears than smiles. Rather than taking the day moment by moment – whatever those moments might have contained – I barreled through, accumulating a lump of disappointments along the way. In the process of manifesting a predetermined experience I had squandered the very real experience that stared me squarely in the eyes. The real sadness was not that I missed out on a picture-perfect holiday, but that I didn’t let the day unfold and simply be what it would be.
Just as becoming a family doesn’t happen overnight, neither does forming its traditions. They don’t materialize out of thin air but gently bubble forth, flowing from one generation into the next. I was so eager to will this Christmas into existence, to pump artificial life into its being, that I failed to let it breathe on its own. When I think about the moments of joy that have marked this past week, they are the ones that sprung forth naturally: a small and impromptu tamal-making party, Maikael and I both being present to watch Abra roll over for the first time, playing a goofy children’s game on Christmas Eve, watching the luminarias flicker in the darkest hour of the night. None of these appeared on any list.
By the time I put Abra to bed on Christmas I was too tired to watch A Christmas Story, but popped it in the DVD player anyway. I only made it half way through the movie before my eyelids became heavy. “I’ll finish it tomorrow,” I promised myself. But real life swept in, leaving it, like so many priorities these days, unfinished. Maybe next year. Or perhaps it’s time to start a new tradition.
The holidays — and life in general — are fraught with expectations. How did you handle the expectations — unrealistic and otherwise — this season? How might you rewrite the experience and do it differently next year?




















